The Colts won the AFC Divisional Round by defeating the Chiefs 38-31. Peyton Manning had 303 total yards and 3 touchdowns.That was the 4th playoff win in franchise history for the Colts. They have won seven playoff games since then.
| Playoff wins |
|---|
| Points | Date | Opp | Result |
| AFC Wild Card Round | Dec 31, 1995 | SD | W 35-20 |
| AFC Divisional Round | Jan 07, 1996 | KC | W 10-7 |
| AFC Wild Card Round | Jan 04, 2004 | DEN | W 41-10 |
| AFC Divisional Round | Jan 11, 2004 | KC | W 38-31 |
| AFC Wild Card Round | Jan 09, 2005 | DEN | W 49-24 |
| AFC Wild Card Round | Jan 06, 2007 | KC | W 23-8 |
| AFC Divisional Round | Jan 13, 2007 | BAL | W 15-6 |
| AFC Championship | Jan 21, 2007 | NE | W 38-34 |
| Feb 04, 2007 | CHI | W 29-17 |
| AFC Divisional Round | Jan 16, 2010 | BAL | W 20-3 |
| AFC Championship | Jan 24, 2010 | NYJ | W 30-17 |